We are here with you hands in hands to facilitate your learning & don't appreciate the idea of copying or replicating solutions. Read More>>

Looking For Something at vustudents.ning.com? Click Here to Search


+ Link For Assignments, GDBs & Online Quizzes Solution


+ Link For Past Papers, Solved MCQs, Short Notes & More

Dear Students! Share your Assignments / GDBs / Quizzes files as you receive in your LMS, So it can be discussed/solved timely. Add Discussion

How to Add New Discussion in Study Group ? Step By Step Guide Click Here.

MGT610 Assignment No 01 Solution & Discussion Due Date:24-01-2018

Raheel & Co. was the only manufacturer of shuttle box for power loom in Pakistan and has monopoly for
the last 60 years. The company was founded in 1958, and established the market of manual loom
shuttle boxes. With the passage of time, they started to make electronic and later smart shuttle boxes
which were controlled by computer. These shuttle boxes are very complicated their technology is
Back in 1998, Mr. Raheel Ashraf died with cancer and the company owned by his two sons, Mr. Aqib and
Mr. Suhail. Bother brothers had decided to take their legal shares and make two more companies, with
their own names. As the business was owned by their family for many years, they had an advantage to
have trust in the market and the emerging business of power loom was at the boost at that time. These
two factors supported them and they made two manufacturing units; one in Karachi and second in
Faisalabad to support the local demand of power loom.
By 2013, government had imposed Value addition tax on textile sector and many people suffered. These
two brothers, who were actually doing separate business but in different geographical location faced
setbacks and reduction in demand. Along with other textile stake holder, they had gone into dialogue
with government officials and with the ministry to trade and development Pakistan. Response was not
good, they had been threatened by government that if they did not reduce the price, government will
subsidized import of shuttle box from China, which resultantly put positive impact on the price of
production. But the idea totally malicious and projected bad impact was disastrous.
Both brothers took decision to visit China and signed agreement with almost all big suppliers of shuttle
box. After that they came back and made a cartel to save their businesses. They had continued their
“soft” monopoly in the market as import from European countries was far much expensive for the
owners of power loom factories. Government tried so much to break that cartel, but remain unable to
do till now. Ministry had also decreased duties for the import of all parts used in power looms, but it did
not put a single dent in the business of two brothers.
In your opinion, is decision taken by brother ethical as they create monopoly against government?
Support your choice while giving 2 supportive arguments.
Special Note: You are also required to consider the fact that both are sole supplier of Shuttle box and
getting maximum profit over decades.

+ How to Follow the New Added Discussions at Your Mail Address?

+ How to Join Subject Study Groups & Get Helping Material?

+ How to become Top Reputation, Angels, Intellectual, Featured Members & Moderators?

+ VU Students Reserves The Right to Delete Your Profile, If?

See Your Saved Posts Timeline

Views: 1486


+ http://bit.ly/vucodes (Link for Assignments, GDBs & Online Quizzes Solution)

+ http://bit.ly/papersvu (Link for Past Papers, Solved MCQs, Short Notes & More)

+ Click Here to Search (Looking For something at vustudents.ning.com?)

+ Click Here To Join (Our facebook study Group)


Replies to This Discussion

yr discuss kru koi tou 

Please Discuss here about this assignment.Thanks

Our main purpose here discussion not just Solution

We are here with you hands in hands to facilitate your learning and do not appreciate the idea of copying or replicating solutions. Read More>>

Discussed & be touched with this discussion. After discussion a perfect solution will come in a result at the end.



For Important Helping Material related to this subject (Solved MCQs, Short Notes, Solved past Papers, E-Books, FAQ,Short Questions Answers & more). You must view all the featured Discussion in this subject group.

For how you can view all the Featured discussions click on the Back to Subject Name Discussions link below the title of this Discussion & then under featured Discussion corner click on the view all link.

Or visit this link 

Click Here For Detail.


.•°How to Download past papers from study groups°•.


Please Click on the below link to see…

.... How to Find Your Subject Study Group & Join .... 


P.S:    Please always try to add the discussion in proper format title like “CS101 Assignment / GDB No 01 Solution & Discussion Due Date: ___________”

Monopolies are not all cancers on societal and economic welfare. In many instances, a monopoly is not only beneficial, but necessary for serving the public interest. Clearly, not all areas of work are conducive to facing the rigors and risks of a competitive marke.

koi tu discuss karo

any one have idea about the right Solution.

tariq malik sb today is last date

any idea??/

Solution pls


The decision taken by brother is ethical as they create monopoly against government because

1st bother brothers allows resources to be used in ways that will produce shortages of those things buyers want and cause them to be sold at higher prices than necessary


2nd    In monopoly markets do not encourage suppliers to use resources in ways that will minimize the resources consumed to produce a certain amount of a commodity. Bother bothers firm is not encouraged to reduce its costs and is therefore not motivated to find less costly methods of production.

Third, a monopoly market allows the seller to introduce price differentials that block consumers from putting together the most satisfying bundle of commodities they can purchase given the commodities available and the money they can spend. Because everyone must buy from the monopoly firm, the firm can set its prices so that some buyers are forced to pay a higher price for the same goods than others.

Page =62 of handouts


Note: take idea from the above and write in ur own words dnt copy paste I m not responsible incase of zero marks

it is ethical becuase they save country money from import the european machinery 

it is ethical because if import the machinery the price of the final product will be high

Monopoly case lag rha hai

kisi k pass solution ni hai kia?????????


Today Top Members 

© 2020   Created by +M.Tariq Malik.   Powered by

Promote Us  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service